23 Easy Pie Recipes Anyone Can Make (Even If You Always Burn the Crust!)
disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. ReallyRushai may receive commission if you make a purchase through a link. read the full disclosure policy for more information. all prices and sales are accurate at time of posting
23 Easy Pie Recipes Anyone Can Make (Even If You Always Burn the Crust!)
Get ready to banish your baking anxiety forever with 23 foolproof easy pie recipes designed for absolute beginners, featuring everything from effortless no-bake icebox treats to clever “press-in” crust short-cuts.
We have all been there. You spend hours meticulously chilling butter, rolling out dough, and crimping edges, only to pull a smoking, charred disaster out of the oven.
Traditional baking can feel like an unforgiving science experiment. But here is a secret the baking elite do not want you to know: you do not need master-level pastry skills to enjoy a slice of homemade heaven.
Whether you are notoriously famous for scorching the edges or simply dread the thought of blind-baking, this list is your ultimate culinary insurance policy.
From foolproof press-in cookie shells to luxurious no-bake fillings that never see an oven, these 23 easy pie recipes guarantee a flawless dessert every single time.
Pin these to your baking boards!
23 Easy Pie Recipes Anyone Can Make (Even If You Always Burn the Crust!)
Grab your rolling pin (or dump it in the trash)—it is time to become a pie hero!
Effortless No-Bake & Icebox Pies
If you cannot trust your oven with a traditional pastry crust, simply skip it. These refreshing, creamy showstoppers rely on simple cookie-crumb bases and the power of your refrigerator.
Easy Pie Recipes
Triple Citrus Creamsicle Pie
A bright, velvety combination of cream cheese, sweetened condensed milk, and fresh citrus juices poured into a pre-made graham cracker shell. It delivers a perfect sweet and sour balance with zero baking required.
Cherry Icebox Pie | restless chipotle
Strawberry Icebox Pie | oh sweet basil
Easy Pie Recipes
Lemon Icebox Pie
Think of this as the ultimate shortcut to lemon meringue. You blend together tart lemon juice, eggs, and sweetened condensed milk, then let your fridge do all the heavy lifting.
While you wait for your dough to rest later, it is the perfect time to mix up a refreshing drink
Check out our 14 Sweet Limoncello Recipes (Drinks, Desserts, & More!) for some delicious kitchen inspiration!
14 Sweet Limoncello Recipes (Drinks, Desserts, & More!)
Soothe your soul on even the coldest of winter nights with 40+ of the most comforting winter dinner recipes.
Easy Pie Recipes
Classic Banoffee Pie
An iconic British dessert that requires no actual cooking. Simply layer store-bought dulce de leche, sliced ripe bananas, and massive billows of freshly whipped cream into a crushed biscuit or cookie crust.
– more Easy Pie Recipes below –
Banana Pudding Icebox Pie | pink owl kitchen
Turtle Pie | the first year blog
Strawberry Lemonade Pie | julies eats and treats
Easy Pie Recipes
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Completely eliminate par-baking and crimping nonsense. You just press crushed cookies into your pie plate, whip up a rich peanut butter mousse filling, and toss the entire thing into the freezer.
Easy Pie Recipes
No-Bake Frozen Margarita Pie
Bring beach vibes right to your kitchen table. This adult-friendly treat uses a salty pretzel crust to perfectly offset a sweet, zesty lime and tequila-infused cream filling.
Sweet & Tender Valentine’s Day Sugar Cookies That’ll Melt In Your Mouth
Love at first bite? These sweet & tender Valentine’s Day sugar cookies will make your heart melt & your tastebuds fall in love
Easy Pie Recipes
Strawberry-Pretzel Ice Cream Pie
A nostalgic summer favorite that blends sweet strawberry puree with creamy vanilla ice cream, anchored beautifully by a crunchy, buttery crushed-pretzel base.
Easy Pie Recipes
Black Forest Ice Cream Cake
It literally does not get easier than this. Build a rustic crust using crushed ice cream cones, fill it with your favorite brand of cherry ice cream, and top with chocolate shavings.
– more Easy Pie Recipes below –
Peach Icebox Pie | restless chipotle
No-Bake S’mores Pie | greens n chocolate
No Bake Peanut Butter Icebox Cake | crazy for crust
“Press-In” & Cheater Crust Masterpieces
Love the warmth of a baked pie but terrified of rolling out traditional dough? These recipes use clever short-cuts like store-bought puff pastry, crumb toppings, or simple “press-in” methods.
Easy Pie Recipes
Chocolate Pudding Pie
Skip the delicate pastry for a rich chocolate cookie or graham cracker crust. Fill it with a silky homemade chocolate pudding and chill until firm.
Peanut Butter Pie | handle the heat
No Bake Marshmallow Pumpkin Pie | together as family
Easy Pie Recipes
Cinnamon Apple Crumb Pie
Instead of wrestling with a complicated lattice top, smother your spiced apples in a mountain of brown sugar and oat streusel. It protects the apples and delivers an irresistible crunch.
Quick & Healthy Summer Dinner Recipes The Whole Family Will Love
Perfect for dining alfresco on warm summer nights, these summer dinner recipes are light, fresh & flavourful
Easy Pie Recipes
Peach and Vanilla Puff-Pastry Pie
Buy a sheet of frozen puff pastry from the grocery store, roll it flat, and pile fresh vanilla-scented peaches into the center. It bakes up into a light, airy, and beautifully flaky tart.
– more Easy Pie Recipes below –
Easy Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake | the novice chef blog
Oreo Pudding Pie | the first year blog
Grasshopper Pie Recipe | dessert now dinner later
Easy Pie Recipes
Raspberry Crumb-Topped Pie
Toss fresh or frozen berries with sugar and cornstarch, dump them into a ready-made crust, and cover with a basic butter-and-flour crumb topping.
Easy Pie Recipes
Chocolate and Coconut Cream Pie
A decadent tropical twist featuring a press-in toasted coconut crust filled with a deep, dark chocolate ganache and coconut custard.
Lazy Girl Tailgate Food: Fun Football Themed Snacks With All Your Childhood Favourites
Skipping the stressful, multi-hour kitchen prep and dive into fun, easy football themed snacks that will actually let you enjoy the party
Easy Pie Recipes
Ruffled Milk Pie with Raspberries
Made by scrunching store-bought phyllo dough into ruffles, baking until crisp, and pouring a simple egg custard and fresh raspberries over top.
Easy Pie Recipes
Coffee Custard Pie
A dream for coffee lovers. This utilizes a simple press-in chocolate wafer crust filled with a smooth, espresso-infused baked egg custard.
– more Easy Pie Recipes below –
Samoas Cookie Pie | averie cooks
Blueberry Crumble Cheesecake Pie | omg chocolate desserts
Toll House Chocolate Chip Pie |a family feast
Foolproof Fruit & Classic Baked Pies
For those who still want the comforting aroma of a classic baked fruit or holiday pie, these specific recipes have built-in safety nets that prevent burnt or soggy crusts.
Easy Pie Recipes
Classic Blueberry Pie
Fruit pies require a long bake time, which acts as your ultimate insurance policy against a soggy bottom. Serve it warm alongside a massive scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Triple Berry Pie | tastes better from scratch
Brown Butter Strawberry Peach Pie | cambrea bakes
Easy Pie Recipes
Blackberry and Dried Apricot Slab Pie
Slab pies offer a much better crust-to-filling ratio than deep-dish pies. Rehydrating the dried apricots ensures the filling stays perfectly jammy without getting watery
Quick & Easy Summer Meals Your Whole Family Will Love
30+ of the most delicious summer meals that your whole family is bound to love!
Easy Pie Recipes
Old-Fashioned Pecan Pie
For such an incredibly fancy and rich dessert, it is actually embarrassingly simple to execute. You just whisk the ingredients together, pour them over pecan halves, and bake until set.
– more Easy Pie Recipes below –
Blueberry Crumble Pie | if you give a blonde a kitchen
Best Dutch Apple Pie Recipe | the food charlatan
Cherry Pie | kristines kitchen blog
Easy Pie Recipes
Grandma’s Pumpkin Pie
A holiday staple that is completely foolproof. Use canned pumpkin puree and a pre-made frozen crust—just whisk the spiced custard filling, pour it in, and bake.
Easy Pie Recipes
Vinegar Pie
If you love southern chess pie, try this punchy alternative. It replaces cornmeal with basic flour and uses a splash of apple cider vinegar to cut through the sweetness with a signature tang.
Magic, One-Skillet & Savory Pies
Pies aren’t just for dessert. These unique options create their own crusts or utilize clever one-pan methods to keep cleanup and stress to an absolute minimum.
Easy Pie Recipes
The Crustless “Impossible” Pie
A true baking miracle. You mix eggs, sugar, butter, flour, milk, and shredded coconut together in a blender and pour it straight into a greased dish. As it bakes, it magically separates to create its own bottom crust and custard layer.
Family Meat Pie | the scran line
Leftover Turkey Hand Pies | shugary sweets
Easy Pie Recipes
Tomato and Roasted Garlic Pie
A savory summer stunner featuring ripe heirloom tomatoes and sweet roasted garlic baked inside a simple, forgiving press-in cornmeal crust.
While you wait for your dough to rest later, it is the perfect time to mix up a refreshing drink
Check out our 14 Sweet Limoncello Recipes (Drinks, Desserts, & More!) for some delicious kitchen inspiration!
What to Sip This Season: Fall Charcuterie Wine Pairing Guide (Cozy Girls’ Night Edition!)
Pour a glass of your favorite vintage and get ready to host the ultimate cozy girls’ night with our guide to the perfect Fall Charcuterie Wine Pairing.
Easy Pie Recipes
One-Skillet Chicken Pot Pie
Eliminate the bottom crust entirely to guarantee you never have to deal with raw, doughy pastry. Cook your creamy chicken filling directly in a skillet, throw a sheet of puff pastry or pre-made pie dough over the top, and bake.
Easy Pie Recipes
Ham and Cheese Hand Pies
Think of these as elevated, gourmet hot pockets. Cut pre-made pie dough into squares, fill with smoky ham and sharp cheddar, fold over, and bake on a sheet pan.
– more Easy Pie Recipes below –
Savory Tomato, Feta, and Basil Pie | hello little home
Beef Chuck Roast Pot Pie | cooking for my soul
Best Irish Steak and Ale Pie Recipe (Pub Style) | the fresh cooky
23 Easy Pie Recipes Anyone Can Make (Even If You Always Burn the Crust!)
There is absolutely no reason to let fear of a burnt, soggy, or crumbling crust keep you away from the joy of home-baked desserts.
Ready to banish your baking anxiety forever?
Head over to the Epicurious Recipe Guide or browse through the Bon Appétit Gallery to find your absolute favorite flavor profile.
Pick out a recipe, head to the kitchen, and show your oven who is boss. Don’t forget to leave a comment below telling us which easy pie you are baking first!
Pin these to your Pie Baking Boards!
Cheers,
You May Also Like
No More Dinner Battles: 15 Kid-Friendly 30-Minute Meals (That Moms Love Too!)
Holiday Cocktails: 30 Must-Try Exquisite Christmas Cocktails
